Go to navigation Go to content
Toll-Free: 800-752-0042
Phone: 757-460-7776
Shapiro & Appleton

Med Mal Case Against UnitedHealth Group Ends With Half A Billion Punitive Damage Award

Comments (0)

What Happened:

A recent story proved just how costly poor medical care can be. Last week a jury in Nevada handed down a massive $500 million punitive damage award in a case against UnitedHealth Group. The punitive damages were on top of the $24 million that had already been awarded for compensatory damages.

The case involved an incident where a doctor’s office was responsible for infecting at least nine patients with Hepatitis C during endoscopy procedures performed in 2007. The plaintiffs blamed the doctor and their insurer for placing upwards of 50,000 people at risk for contracting a blood-borne illness.

The case was an unusual one not only because of the size of the jury award, but because the insurer was sued along with the doctor. The patients argued that United Healthcare was partially responsible given its decision to accept a low bid contract from the doctor who was responsible for the infections. United Healthcare accepted the cheap contract despite having been warned that the doctor was known for speeding through procedures and had previously placed patients at risk for blood-borne diseases. The plaintiffs argued that United Healthcare knew or should have known that the doctor was trying to make as much money as possible by quickly processing high volumes of patients.

Though the $500 million award is stunning in its size, it is actually half as much as the plaintiffs were hoping for, having asked the jury for $1 billion in punitive damages. The jury settled on a total of $500 million, $270 million being assessed to the Health Plan of Nevada and $230 million to Sierra Health Services, both UnitedHealth affiliates.

The Virginia Injury Attorney’s Perspective:

Though the amount seems stunning, the point of a punitive damage award is to punish wrongdoers so that they and others will have an incentive to avoid making similar mistakes in the future. UnitedHealth Group had revenues of $102 billion in 2011 and a profit of more than $5 billion. If the award had not been so large then it would likely not have been sufficient to force real change on the part of the company. 

Virginia has a medical malpractice ceiling that is currently just over $2 million. This damage cap applies to all damages and for all the defendants in the case. This means that a settlement with one defendant reduces the maximum liability of the others, because the cap limits the total amount recoverable for an injury to a patient, regardless of the number of theories or defendants. These limits serve as unfair restrictions on what can be recovered by a patient or family that has suffered grave harm due to someone else’s bad acts.

Virginia also has a ceiling on financially punishing awards, also known as punitive damages. Virginia limits punitive damage recovery to $350,000 in every case, regardless of its severity. This means that even if a jury is outraged by a defendant’s bad conduct, its hands are tied in handing down especially punitive awards. Sadly, Virginia juries would never be allowed to hand down such a harsh award as the one discussed in this case. Despite vigorous protests, the damage caps have been upheld previously in Virginia, although several state supreme courts have ruled they are unconstitutional for one reason or another.

Potentially Helpful Info:

If you or a loved one has been the victim of a medical error or complication, you should consult with an experienced Virginia (VA) medical malpractice lawyer who has successfully handled similar med mal cases in the past. Our firm enjoys a reputation of experience and success while representing victims in medical malpractice cases against doctors, hospitals, and other health care providers. We approach each case individually to provide the resources, knowledge and experience to achieve success on behalf of our clients.

If you or a member of your family has been harmed by a Virginia (VA) doctor’s misdiagnosis, mistake or negligence, you can begin to learn about your legal rights and options for seeking compensation by downloading this free report.

Have Questions? Check Out Our Firm’s FAQs.

If you or a loved one has been injured at the hands of a medical professional, chances are you are confused about your options and may not know where to turn for help. To learn more about medical malpractice cases, check out this online library of Virginia (VA) attorneys’ answers to frequently asked questions regarding medical malpractice lawsuits.

Here's a video discussing the process of reaching a medical malpractice settlement:

CA

Richard N. Shapiro
Personal Injury & Wrongful Death Lawyer Serving Va Beach, Norfolk, Chesapeake & all of Virginia
Be the first to comment!

Post a Comment

To reply to this message, enter your reply in the box labeled "Message", hit "Post Message."

Name:*

Email:* (will not be published)

Message:*

Notify me of follow-up comments via email.

Avvo The Best lawyers in America Super lawyers Best Law Firms US News Verdicts and Settlements AV LexisNexis

Live Chat