Wrongful Death
No Financial Recovery For You, No Legal Fee
Request Your Free Consultation

Truck Accident Wrongful Death Results in $2.25 Million Settlement

What Happened

Our client was a tractor-trailer operator who stopped on the paved shoulder of Interstate 95 (I-95) in Emporia, Virginia (VA) to check the safety of his load. At the same time and place, the defendant – also a commercial truck driver – veered off the interstate highway lane of travel and struck/sideswiped our client as he stood beside his truck trailer examining it. Our commercial truck driver client died from his injuries at a local hospital within hours of the collision.

His widow retained our Virginia and North Carolina wrongful death lawyers to investigate the circumstances of the collision and represent her and their family, which included several young minor children. In cases like this, involving a North Carolina resident involved in a wrongful death that occurred inside the state of Virginia, our dual-licensed Virginia and North Carolina attorneys have the kind of experience necessary to consider personal injury legal issues in both bordering states.

The potentially responsible truck driver died several days after this collision from medical complications arising from an underlying illness, one not caused by this particular trucking accident.  This meant within a very short time after the trucking collision, both truck drivers died.

Key Legal Strategies

North Carolina wrongful death attorney Randy Appleton took swift action to obtain medical records of the potentially responsible truck driver, because it was obvious that he had an underlying medical condition which he died from, that might have had an impact on his ability to operate the commercial truck in the first place. Commercial truck drivers are required to obtain a commercial driver’s license and they must undergo periodic physical examinations and will not be cleared to operate commercial trucks if they have any major health condition that could seriously impact their driving capabilities. One question Randy Appleton needed to get answers to was whether the truck driver had possibly concealed his medical condition from his trucking company employer and from the doctors conducting any physical examinations in connection with his commercial driver's license (CDL).

As soon as the suit was filed, Virginia/North Carolina wrongful death attorney Randy Appleton sent a request for production of documents to the trucking company seeking the at-fault truck driver's medical records. In addition, Randy pursued other medical records he learned of, by document subpoena in Georgia, after tracking down some of the medical doctors that treated the truck driver who died within a week of the collision.

After he obtained pertinent medical records, truck accident attorney Randy Appleton retained a medical doctor in order to establish that the truck driver knew or should have known that his pre-existing medical condition could interfere with his driving capabilities. We filed suit against the truck driver's employer on the basis that their driver had what is called a sudden medical emergency, which can create a legal excuse for carelessness or negligence, but it must be sudden, and it must not be foreseeable to the truck driver operating their truck before the collision occurs.

The potentially responsible truck driver, through his employer, claimed that there was contributory negligence on our client who was tending to his tractor-trailer. The defendant's argument was that our client should not have been on the shoulder, and should have placed warning cones around his tractor-trailer before he was struck and killed.

Result - $2.25 Million for the Family of Our Client

A pretrial settlement conference took place with a United States Magistrate Judge. Our North Carolina truck accident injury attorneys prepared detailed written materials to provide the magistrate judge so that he could understand the strength of our case and the immense loss to the widow and to the young children having lost their father.

The case did not settle at the first settlement conference presided over by the U.S. magistrate Judge. However, in the period of time immediately after that conference, the parties agreed to settle the case for $2.25 million.

Our work did not end with the negotiation of the settlement because Randy Appleton was instrumental in helping the widow set up structured settlements that provide for growth of the settlement funds for the minor children so that at age 18 these funds increase in value and are maximized tax-free. How those settlement funds grow over the years should be carefully considered by experienced personal injury lawyers.  

The wrongful death settlement was approved in Virginia, but the widow and estate representative resided in North Carolina.  This meant considerations of how the settlement monies were to be divided to the wrongful death beneficiaries under either VA or NC law was important.  Accordingly, Randy worked with the widow to set up personal injury structured settlements that provide for the growth of the settlement funds in favor of the young minors. 

Law Firm Staff

  • Randall E. Appleton, Attorney
  • Ed Booth, Attorney
  • Becky W. and Roz H., Paralegals


  • Eastern District Federal Court, Richmond, VA


  • October 2016


$2.25 Million Settlement